The Social Justice Promise of Psychedelic Decriminalization

Sarah Gersten • September 25, 2023

Originally published as an op-ed in The Crime Reporter.


Across the nation, we’ve seen an exponential expansion in jurisdictions attempting to pass legislation to decriminalize certain drugs–most recently psychedelics. Since 2019, 25 states have considered 74 psychedelic reform bills, 10 of which were successfully enacted. Currently, there are 32 pieces of active psychedelics legislative initiatives, and now, a bill to legalize certain naturally occurring psychedelics in California is headed to Governor Newsom’s desk. This progress comes on the heels of the past decade's monumental shift in drug policy reform and the broad legalization of cannabis. Today, 23 states and the District of Columbia have fully legalized cannabis, and there are now only four states that have no form of legal cannabis. While efforts to legalize cannabis have made tremendous progress that the psychedelics space can hope to emulate, these initiatives continue to fall short in the area of retroactive criminal justice–a failing that drug policy advocates now have the opportunity to remedy with broader decriminalization measures.


Across the nation, we’ve seen an exponential expansion in jurisdictions attempting to pass legislation to decriminalize certain drugs–most recently psychedelics. A
recent analysis of US legislation related to psychedelics found that since 2019, 25 states have considered 74 psychedelic reform bills, 10 of which were successfully enacted. By the end of 2022, there were 36 pieces of active psychedelic drug legislative initiatives, and now, a bill to legalize certain naturally occurring psychedelics in California is headed to Governor Newsom’s desk. Today, 23 states and the District of Columbia have fully legalized cannabis, and there are now only four states that have no form of legal cannabis. While efforts to legalize cannabis have made tremendous progress that the psychedelics space can hope to emulate, these initiatives continue to fall short in the area of retroactive criminal justice–a failing that drug policy advocates now have the opportunity to remedy with broader decriminalization measures.



When the first adult-use ballot initiatives passed in states like Colorado and Washington, the political climate dictated that advocates focus on getting bills passed without comprehensive criminal and social justice provisions. Even though these inclusions are now standard practice for omnibus legalization bills, they often fall short. Social equity programs have been rife with problems, and profitable businesses for those most impacted by the War on Drugs have largely failed to materialize.


Similarly, the criminal justice initiatives meant to repair the harms of prohibition have been a mixed bag. Many states have successfully used cannabis legalization as a means to implement broad reforms–including automatically clearing tens of thousands of criminal records and reducing criminal sentences. Legalization initiatives have now become the broadest and best examples of retroactivity, a concept typically absent in our criminal legal system. Generally, when a law changes, that change applies only prospectively. The criminal justice measures tied to the change in the legal status of cannabis, though, have given us a proof of concept for providing retroactive relief for individuals who may have suffered severe criminal consequences for activity that the general public–and our criminal legal system–now deems acceptable.


That’s not to say that legalization has been a silver bullet for implementing retroactive reforms–ten years in, and we are still figuring out best practices for ensuring relief is guaranteed for eligible populations. Take California, where our organization, Last Prisoner Project, has worked to pass clean-up legislation to finally fulfill the original promise of the state’s Prop 64, which created an adult-use market for cannabis and included several  social equity and criminal justice provisions. Despite such language being included in the original bill, there have been significant delays and issues with implementation. Even after the passage of two pieces of follow-on legislation to address the problems with cannabis record clearance in the state, there are still tens of thousands of Californians waiting for relief.


This is not to downplay the potential for impactful reforms tied to legalization measures. While we continue to face obstacles in advancing cannabis justice, we now have the opportunity to look back on the complexities and pitfalls of successfully joining social justice efforts with drug policy reforms and to take these lessons into the next stage of this movement. As more and more states look to decriminalize psychedelics, it will be imperative that we leverage the successful models utilized for cannabis reform early on. 


Unfortunately, like those early cannabis legalization initiatives, the vast majority of psychedelic reform bills, including SB 58 in California, are absent any social or criminal justice reform. In fact, the 2019 iteration of the bill was the only measure to include any criminal justice provisions (the original language would have dismissed and sealed prior drug convictions that would no longer be unlawful) but that language was removed in the senate. The understandable concern from advocates is that a legalization measure that has the potential to create significant progress for drug policy would fail due to these additional criminal justice reform provisions. But excluding these crucial components from these bills is a mistake we do not need to repeat.


The political landscape has changed immensely in the past decade. Along with the acknowledgment of the failures of prohibition and the War on Drugs, our criminal legal landscape is now marked by a broad consensus to end the country’s reliance on over-criminalization and our mass incarceration epidemic. Luckily, the progress we’ve made on the drug policy front can and must be leveraged to make advancements to our criminal legal system. To merely pass decriminalization laws is not enough to undo the injustices of our nation’s failed War on Drugs. We must ensure that retroactive criminal legal reforms are part of psychedelic decriminalization measures. There is a massive opportunity for true criminal justice reform through progressive changes to our criminal codes. 


Let’s not wait another decade to act on it.


About the Author:


Sarah Gersten
is the Executive Director and General Counsel for the Last Prisoner Project. Throughout her career Sarah has worked at the intersection of cannabis legalization and criminal justice reform. After working as an attorney at a congressional agency where she focused on legislative policy, Sarah co-founded a cannabis-centric law firm where she led the firm's pro bono initiative, taking on expungement and record-sealing cases. Sarah went on to co-found and serve as CEO for a legal tech startup that offers affordable legal solutions for small cannabis business owners, as well as free expungement services. Sarah is a member of the International Cannabis Bar Association, the NORML Legal Committee, and the National Lawyers Guild. She received her BA from Tulane University and her JD from Harvard Law School.

By Stephen Post April 22, 2025
At the Last Prisoner Project (LPP), we know that true justice means more than legalization—it means clearing the records of those who were criminalized under outdated cannabis laws. Today, we celebrate a major step forward in that fight for justice as Governor Wes Moore signs SB 432, the Expungement Reform Act of 2025 , into law. In Maryland, where Governor Wes Moore made history last year by issuing the nation’s most sweeping cannabis pardon order, we are now happy to see this next step in reform. A criminal record—whether for a conviction or even just an arrest—can create lasting obstacles to employment, housing, education, and other opportunities. The impact is not just personal; according to research from the Center for Economic and Policy Research, the U.S. economy loses between $78 and $87 billion annually due to employment barriers faced by people with criminal records. These collateral consequences compound the injustices of the War on Drugs and disproportionately affect communities already marginalized by systemic inequities. SB 432 simplifies the expungement process, removing unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles and making it easier for individuals to clear their records. The bill will help thousands of Marylanders—many of whom have already served their sentences—access new opportunities and contribute fully to their communities. “People in Maryland were living with the unconscionable reality that any probation violation, from a missed appointment to even decades-old possession of small amounts of now legal cannabis, categorically barred them from ever expunging their record,” said Heather Warnken, Executive Director of the Center for Criminal Justice Reform at the University of Baltimore School of Law . “The Expungement Reform Act has addressed this and more, removing barriers to opportunity for thousands held back by their past record. Like Governor Moore’s historic mass pardon, this victory is the product of true partnership, and an incredible step forward for our state.” SB 432 builds on the momentum of Governor Moore’s bold action in 2024, when he issued the largest cannabis pardon order in U.S. history, granting relief to over 175,000 Marylanders with low-level cannabis convictions . However, as we have long emphasized, a pardon—while powerful—does not automatically clear someone’s record. Until now, many of those same individuals still had to navigate a complicated, costly, and often inaccessible process to obtain full relief. Now, thanks to the passage of SB 432, that process will become significantly more accessible—and, in key cases, automatic. This is a vital step toward making sure the promise of cannabis reform includes real, tangible outcomes for those most affected by prohibition. “At Last Prisoner Project, our mission is to secure freedom and rebuild the lives of those disproportionately impacted by the War on Drugs,” said Liz Budnitz, Lead Counsel of the Cannabis Justice Initiative at Last Prisoner Project , who was present at the signing ceremony. “SB 432 embodies the idea that legalization must come with justice and repair for those who paid the price for misguided drug policies. We are proud to support reforms like this bill and look forward to continuing to advocate for policies that prioritize the full reintegration of justice-impacted individuals.” Adrian Rocha, LPP’s Policy Director and a member of Governor Moore’s expungement roundtable , added, "Last Prisoner Project commends Governor Wes Moore for signing SB 432, the Expungement Reform Act of 2025, into law. By creating a more efficient and accessible pathway for individuals to expunge cannabis-related convictions and seek post-conviction relief, this bill is a crucial step in addressing the harms caused by decades of cannabis criminalization in Maryland. We are thrilled that more Marylanders will now be able to move forward with their lives, access new opportunities, and contribute fully to their communities.” Maryland now joins 12 other states that have implemented state-initiated expungement for certain offenses, recognizing that individuals should not be required to navigate complex legal systems to obtain relief they are already entitled to. This victory represents not just a legislative achievement, but a powerful moment of healing and restoration. We thank Governor Moore, the Maryland General Assembly, and all our partners and advocates who helped make this bill a reality. But our work is far from over. Cannabis justice means full, automatic relief—not just in Maryland, but across the country. And at the Last Prisoner Project, we’re committed to making that vision real. Watch the full bill signing below and read past coverage here .
By Stephen Post April 18, 2025
Proposed Legislation Marks a Critical Step Toward Ending Criminalization and Repairing Harms from the War on Drugs Washington, D.C. – Today, the Last Prisoner Project released a statement applauding the introduction of two bipartisan bills aimed at ending federal cannabis prohibition and preparing for a post-prohibition regulatory framework. Reps. Dave Joyce (R-OH), Max Miller (R-OH) and Dina Titus (D-NV) announced on Thursday that they’ve filed the Strengthening the Tenth Amendment Through Entrusting States (STATES) 2.0 Act. This bill would end federal marijuana prohibition in states that have legalized it, while providing for a basic federal regulatory framework for cannabis products. Rep. Dave Joyce (R-OH) also introduced the Preparing Regulators Effectively for a Post-Prohibition Adult-Use Regulated Environment Act (PREPARE) Act , which is being sponsored by House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY). This bill would direct the attorney general to create a commission charged with making recommendations on a regulatory system for cannabis that models what’s currently in place for alcohol. “These bipartisan bills are a critical step forward toward ending the federal government’s failed war on cannabis,” said Stephen Post, Strategic Communications Manager at the Last Prisoner Project . “By respecting the will of states, addressing regulatory uncertainty, and acknowledging the urgent need for reform, this legislation lays the groundwork for a smarter, fairer approach to cannabis policy. Going forward, we also urge lawmakers to ensure that federal cannabis legislation also include robust provisions for sentence modification, automatic record clearance and retroactive relief. Otherwise, we risk building this industry on the backs of those still suffering the consequences of outdated, unjust laws.” The Last Prisoner Project urges lawmakers on both sides of the aisle to support these measures and continue working toward a more just and equitable post-prohibition future. The Cannabis Unity Coalition, the largest bipartisan coalition of cannabis advocacy, industry, and grassroots organizations, is mobilizing for the Cannabis Unity Week of Action, taking place April 29th - May 1st, 2025, in Washington, D.C. This multi-day event will unite advocates, impacted individuals, and industry leaders to pressure Congress and the Trump administration to fully legalize cannabis and implement retroactive relief measures for those affected by prohibition-era policies. Click here to learn more .
By Stephen Post April 17, 2025
Thursday, April 17th (Washington D.C.) - As Americans across the country celebrate the 4/20 cannabis holiday this weekend, tens of thousands of people remain incarcerated for cannabis-related offenses, licensed cannabis businesses are struggling, community uplift funds are stalled, and the federal government's cannabis reclassification process is in limbo. Despite significant progress in cannabis legalization, with 24 states and Washington, D.C. legalizing adult-use cannabis, the fight for full legalization and retroactive relief is more urgent than ever. To mobilize the 70% of the public that supports legalization into political pressure, the Cannabis Unity Coalition, the largest bipartisan coalition of cannabis advocacy, industry, and grassroots organizations, is mobilizing for the Cannabis Unity Week of Action , taking place April 29th - May 1st, 2025, in Washington, D.C. This multi-day event will unite advocates, impacted individuals, and industry leaders to pressure Congress and the Trump administration to fully legalize cannabis and implement retroactive relief measures for those affected by prohibition-era policies. The week will start on Tuesday with a congressional press conference in the morning followed by a welcome ceremony in the U.S. Capitol Visitor Center starting at 2pm. Wednesday will be dedicated to our Lobby Day where attendees will meet with their elected officials on Capitol Hill to advocate for cannabis reform. Lastly, events will conclude Thursday evening with a Cannabis Freedom Rally outside the White House from 4-9pm to honor those still incarcerated for cannabis and demand their freedom via presidential clemency. As part of our 4/20 clemency campaign , Ben & Jerry’s will be joining the rally to serve free ice cream to help build awareness and mobilize grassroots efforts to demand clemency from governors across the country. The Cannabis Unity Coalition is made up of a broad array of advocate groups span across political boundaries and includes members of the Marijuana Justice Coalition (MJC) like Drug Policy Alliance (DPA), National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML), Veterans Cannabis Coalition, and Parabola Center; members of the Cannabis Freedom Alliance (CFA) like the Reason Foundation and Law Enforcement Action Partnership (LEAP); Students for Sensible Drug Policy (SSDP), which is a member of both coalitions; and industry groups like, National Craft Cannabis Coalition, National Cannabis Industry Association (NCIA), Minority Cannabis Business Association (MCBA), Indigenous Cannabis Industry Association (ICIA), Asian Cannabis Roundtable, and National Association of Black Cannabis Lawyers (NABCL), Freedom Grow, Marijuana Justice, Doctors for Drug Policy Reform, United Food and Commercial Workers Union (UFCW), Supernova Women, Minorities for Medical Marijuana, DCMJ, Just Leadership USA (JLUSA), National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, National Coalition for Drug Legalization and the Marijuana Policy Project (MPP), Mission Green, Latinas in Cannabis, the Equity Trade Network, Cannademix, and Free My Weed Man. “False conservatives and cheerleaders for big government have, for decades, hidden behind the drug war as a justification for a government that’s so intrusive it can monitor whether peaceful people have a few grams of cannabis in their pocket.” Said Geoffrey Lawrence of the REASON foundation . “The PATRIOT Act equates marijuana users with terrorists and erects a massive surveillance state to spy on the financial transactions of every American, whether or not they smoke marijuana. And for what? Marijuana users are not inherently violent criminals and the federal government should have no role in the criminalization of this natural substance.” "Working people deserve a better deal when it comes to criminal justice reform, specifically in Cannabis," said Hugh Giordano, UFCW Labor Union Representative . "Working people can't afford legal costs when dealing the Cannabis offenses, which can lead to unfair sentencing and harm working communities." "Regardless of which party is in control of Congress and the White House, ending federal marijuana criminalization and repairing harms caused by it remains a top priority for the Drug Policy Alliance. As long as marijuana is still illegal at the federal level, communities of color and low-income people will continue to suffer the most through incarceration, family separation, and economic hardship due to marijuana arrests.” Said Maritza Perez, Director of Federal Affairs for the Drug Policy Alliance. “With federal marijuana legalization enjoying majority support across all political affiliations, efforts like the Cannabis Unity Week of Action that bring together groups from a variety of political ideologies should show Congress and the White House that ending federal marijuana prohibition is an issue everyone can get behind." Bill Levers, CEO of Freedom Grow, said, “Unity Day 2025 represents a long-overdue collective awakening. At Freedom Grow, we’ve dedicated years to uplifting the voices and lives of people still serving time for cannabis convictions—people forgotten by the system while the industry thrives. This day in Washington D.C. is about more than policy—it’s about people. It’s about showing lawmakers, and the nation, that there’s a unified, unstoppable force demanding not just the descheduling of cannabis, but true retroactive justice. When we stand united with all other prisoner outreach programs, we send a clear message: cannabis freedom isn’t freedom until it includes everyone—especially those who paid the highest price.” "The legal cannabis industry proudly provides adult consumers and medical patients with safe, lab-tested, high-quality products while supporting hundreds of thousands of U.S. jobs and generating billions in tax revenue. Despite this progress, outdated federal prohibition policies continue to jeopardize public safety by preventing the legal industry from reaching its full potential to displace the illicit marijuana market — even as a supermajority of voters support federal reform.” Said Aaron Smith, Executive Director of the National Cannabis Industry Association . “We look forward to once again participating in this Unity Week of Action, standing with our partners and fellow advocates to call for a more equitable, compassionate, and sensible approach to federal cannabis policy." Jason Ortiz, Director of Strategic Initiatives at the Last Prisoner Project said, "No matter who is in office we will not stop pushing for legalization until we finally end the war on our community. There are still hundreds of thousands of cannabis arrests every year and we will remind Congress that the vast majority of our country, and even 55% of republicans, support legalization. Now it’s on us to push congress to do the right thing, and that’s exactly what we intend to do this Unity Week.” As more organizations join our fight, individuals interested in attending Cannabis Unity Week can sign up for updates here . Additionally, if you have any questions, you can read this FAQ document or watch our recorded information session for more info. Those who can’t join us in D.C. can still participate virtually by contacting your federal representatives to #DecriminalizeNow, urging your governor to grant clemency to those in your state, and following along through livestream. Learn more and take action at LPP.la/CannabisUnityWeek . Press contact: Stephen Post LPP Communications Manager stephen@lastprisonerproejct.org